Engineering is one of consulting’s most reliable talent pipelines (I say this having come through it myself!). The route from major infrastructure programmes into boutique and Big Four consulting has become well-trodden, and for good reason. Engineers and consultants share more intellectual DNA than the job titles suggest.

But there’s a pattern I see often. The engineer joins a consultancy, gets promoted quickly through the junior grades, is clearly one of the team’s strongest performers, and then, somewhere around Director level, something stops working. Not for everyone. But for enough people that it is worth understanding why.

So, the short answer to the title question is: yes, and no. Brilliant junior consultants, often. Natural senior leaders and business developers, not always.

Why engineers thrive in the early years

The skills at the core of consulting - framing a problem, breaking it into logical components, building structured analysis, working to tight deadlines in complex multi-stakeholder environments - are things that engineers are trained in from day one.

A structural engineer working on a major infrastructure programme learns to use product breakdown structures the way consultants use issue trees. They understand, from the ground up, how to move things forward in organisations with complicated governance, multiple stakeholders, and competing priorities. Anyone who has worked on a programme like HS2 will recognise that environment. You learn to use formal structures and informal relationships in equal measure, because neither alone is enough.

Our analytical capabilities are often exceptional. I have worked alongside engineers whose backgrounds transferred directly into consulting work in ways that surprised even them. The mathematics, the structured thinking, the comfort with complexity: it turns out to be the same.

Add a generally strong work ethic, an allergy to missing deadlines, and the ability to explain complicated things clearly to non-specialists, and you have someone who can do a lot of what consulting requires from the moment they walk in.

Where the plateau starts

The problem is not about introversion or about people skills in general. That is a caricature, and an unhelpful one.

The problem is more specific. As a consultant becomes more senior, the expectation shifts, from technical delivery towards client impact, influence, and relationship development.

Two things that came naturally as a junior consultant start to feel less comfortable.

The first is elevating the conversation. We are trained to go deep. When we are in a room with a client, we can provide enormous value by engaging on a technical level. But our more senior clients often care less about the technical outcome and more about the strategic or commercial one. Making that shift requires a different kind of curiosity, and a willingness to leave the territory where you feel most confident.

The second is building genuine human connection. Not rapport, not professional courtesy, but the kind of intimacy that underlies trusted advisor relationships. We want to help by solving a problem. I recognise that impulse in myself. The difficulty is that being a trusted advisor sometimes requires the opposite. It requires the ability to hold space, to resist the urge to provide an answer, to let someone talk without steering them toward a logical conclusion. Some situations do not lend themselves well to someone who wants to solve a problem, provide an answer, and apply logic. In fact, those three things taken together describe an engineer fairly well and, for much of my career, they described me. In those moments, what the situation actually requires is something more intangible.

Getting comfortable with ‘failure’

As seniority increases, so does the expectation around sales and business development. Everything above applies here, but now there is an additional factor.

We are not used to failing.

That is not a criticism; it is the point. If you are designing a bridge, failure is not an acceptable outcome. Engineering education, professional standards, and the nature of the work itself all create people with high standards, high accuracy, and a deep discomfort with getting it wrong.

Business development does not work like that. You will not win every bid. The ratio of effort to outcome in sales can be humbling, even when you have done everything right. Learning to sit with that, to reframe a missed opportunity as simply not yet being successful with a particular client, is a real psychological adjustment. It held me back too, for longer than I would like to admit. A fear of failure, I think, is what holds a lot of technically talented engineers back from fully stepping into senior commercial roles.

What consulting firms can do

First, anticipate the plateau. Engineers often move through junior and mid-level grades at pace, which can mask the development needs that will matter at Director level and above. If someone with an engineering background is clearly talented, it is worth having the conversation early about what seniority will require - before the plateau, not after.

Second, train, coach, and role model the human side. Many senior consulting leaders do this naturally, but are less deliberate about passing it on. Feedback in the moment, noticing when someone has jumped to a solution rather than letting a conversation breathe, can do a lot of work.

Third, introduce business development awareness early. Not necessarily the mechanics of proposals and pitches, but the culture of building relationships with commercial intent, and the normalisation of not winning every time.

The engineers who become outstanding trusted advisors do exist. I like to think I’ve made a lot of progress along that road. But I had specific experiences and specific support that made the difference. The goal is to make that development more deliberate, and to give more of your talented technical people the chance of getting there.

The Skilled Consultant is written by Deri Hughes and Colin Mann, Managing Directors of Honeycomb Consulting Skills Training. We help consulting leaders develop exceptional teams with world-class training to support every career transition.

Visit Honeycomb's Website

If this article raised a question about your own team, do drop a comment below or book a 30-minute call with Deri or with Colin to discuss how we could help you.

Leave a comment

Subscribe now to receive future articles and webinar recordings, or share this one with someone who may find it valuable.

Subscribe now

Share

Do engineers make good consultants?